Detecting beats in the photoplethysmogram: benchmarking open-source algorithms

Benchmark Model Rank Results
photoplethysmography-ppg-beat-detection-on-mimic-perform-testingMSPTD: MultiScale Peak & Trough Detection#1F1 score: 97.5
photoplethysmography-ppg-beat-detection-on-mimic-perform-testingAMPD: Automatic Multiscale Peak Detection#2F1 score: 97.2
photoplethysmography-ppg-beat-detection-on-mimic-perform-testingqppg: Adapted Onset Detector#3F1 score: 96.9
photoplethysmography-ppg-beat-detection-on-mimic-perform-testingABD: Automatic Beat Detection#4F1 score: 96.8
photoplethysmography-ppg-beat-detection-on-mimic-perform-testingPulses#5F1 score: 96.6
photoplethysmography-ppg-beat-detection-on-mimic-perform-testingHeartPy#6F1 score: 95.6
photoplethysmography-ppg-beat-detection-on-mimic-perform-testingSPAR: Symmetric Projection Attractor Reconstruction#7F1 score: 95.3
photoplethysmography-ppg-beat-detection-on-mimic-perform-testingERMA: EventRelated Moving Averages#8F1 score: 93.6
photoplethysmography-ppg-beat-detection-on-mimic-perform-testingIMS: Incremental Merge Segmentation#9F1 score: 93.6
photoplethysmography-ppg-beat-detection-on-mimic-perform-testingPWD: Pulse Wave Delineator#10F1 score: 92.9
photoplethysmography-ppg-beat-detection-on-mimic-perform-testingCOppg: Percentile Peak Detector#11F1 score: 92.4
photoplethysmography-ppg-beat-detection-on-mimic-perform-testingPDA: Peak Detection Algorithm#12F1 score: 92.2
photoplethysmography-ppg-beat-detection-on-mimic-perform-testingWFD: Wavelet Foot Delineation#13F1 score: 86.5
photoplethysmography-ppg-beat-detection-on-mimic-perform-testingATM: Adaptive Threshold Method#14F1 score: 71.1
photoplethysmography-ppg-beat-detection-on-mimic-perform-testingSWT: Stationary Wavelet Transform#15F1 score: 59.0
photoplethysmography-ppg-heart-rate-estimation-on-mimic-perform-testingMSPTD: MultiScale Peak & Trough Detection#1MAPE: 2.4
photoplethysmography-ppg-heart-rate-estimation-on-mimic-perform-testingAMPD: Automatic Multiscale Peak Detection#2MAPE: 2.9
photoplethysmography-ppg-heart-rate-estimation-on-mimic-perform-testingABD: Automatic Beat Detection#3MAPE: 3.3
photoplethysmography-ppg-heart-rate-estimation-on-mimic-perform-testingPulses#4MAPE: 3.3
photoplethysmography-ppg-heart-rate-estimation-on-mimic-perform-testingqppg: Adapted Onset Detector#5MAPE: 3.5
photoplethysmography-ppg-heart-rate-estimation-on-mimic-perform-testingSPAR: Symmetric Projection Attractor Reconstruction#6MAPE: 4.6
photoplethysmography-ppg-heart-rate-estimation-on-mimic-perform-testingHeartPy#7MAPE: 4.9
photoplethysmography-ppg-heart-rate-estimation-on-mimic-perform-testingIMS: Incremental Merge Segmentation#8MAPE: 7.7
photoplethysmography-ppg-heart-rate-estimation-on-mimic-perform-testingPDA: Peak Detection Algorithm#9MAPE: 7.8
photoplethysmography-ppg-heart-rate-estimation-on-mimic-perform-testingERMA: EventRelated Moving Averages#10MAPE: 7.9
photoplethysmography-ppg-heart-rate-estimation-on-mimic-perform-testingPWD: Pulse Wave Delineator#11MAPE: 8.4
photoplethysmography-ppg-heart-rate-estimation-on-mimic-perform-testingCOppg: Percentile Peak Detector#12MAPE: 9.6
photoplethysmography-ppg-heart-rate-estimation-on-mimic-perform-testingWFD: Wavelet Foot Delineation#13MAPE: 17.5
photoplethysmography-ppg-heart-rate-estimation-on-mimic-perform-testingATM: Adaptive Threshold Method#14MAPE: 38.5
photoplethysmography-ppg-heart-rate-estimation-on-mimic-perform-testingSWT: Stationary Wavelet Transform#15MAPE: 51.0