Break the Ceiling: Stronger Multi-scale Deep Graph Convolutional Networks

Benchmark Model Rank Results
node-classification-on-pubmed-0-1Truncated Krylov#1Accuracy: 77.21%
node-classification-on-pubmed-0-1Snowball (linear + tanh)#3Accuracy: 75.30%
node-classification-on-pubmed-0-1Snowball (tanh)#4Accuracy: 74.40%
node-classification-on-pubmed-0-1Snowball (linear)#5Accuracy: 73.83%
node-classification-on-citeseer-1Truncated Krylov#2Accuracy: 69.03%
node-classification-on-citeseer-1Snowball (linear + tanh)#4Accuracy: 67.07%
node-classification-on-citeseer-1Snowball (linear)#5Accuracy: 65.85%
node-classification-on-citeseer-1Snowball (tanh)#6Accuracy: 64.23%
node-classification-on-cora-1Truncated Krylov#2Accuracy: 78.15%
node-classification-on-cora-1Snowball (linear + tanh)#4Accuracy: 74.79%
node-classification-on-cora-1Snowball (tanh)#5Accuracy: 74.78%
node-classification-on-cora-1Snowball (linear)#6Accuracy: 73.10%
node-classification-on-pubmed-0-03Truncated Krylov#2Accuracy: 71.11%
node-classification-on-pubmed-0-03Snowball (linear)#3Accuracy: 68.12%
node-classification-on-pubmed-0-03Snowball (tanh)#5Accuracy: 62.61%
node-classification-on-pubmed-0-03Snowball (linear + tanh)#6Accuracy: 61.94%
node-classification-on-pubmed-0-05Truncated Krylov#2Accuracy: 72.57%
node-classification-on-pubmed-0-05Snowball (linear)#3Accuracy: 70.04%
node-classification-on-pubmed-0-05Snowball (linear + tanh)#5Accuracy: 69.45%
node-classification-on-pubmed-0-05Snowball (tanh)#6Accuracy: 68.99%
node-classification-on-citeseer-0-5Truncated Krylov#3Accuracy: 64.64%
node-classification-on-citeseer-0-5Snowball (tanh)#4Accuracy: 62.05%
node-classification-on-citeseer-0-5Snowball (linear + tanh)#5Accuracy: 61.99%
node-classification-on-citeseer-0-5Snowball (linear)#6Accuracy: 59.41%
node-classification-on-cora-0-5Truncated Krylov#3Accuracy: 74.89%
node-classification-on-cora-0-5Snowball (tanh)#4Accuracy: 71.36%
node-classification-on-cora-0-5Snowball (linear)#5Accuracy: 69.99%
node-classification-on-cora-0-5Snowball (linear + tanh)#6Accuracy: 67.76%
node-classification-on-cora-3Truncated Krylov#3Accuracy: 81.92%
node-classification-on-cora-3Snowball (linear)#4Accuracy: 80.96%
node-classification-on-cora-3Snowball (tanh)#5Accuracy: 80.72%
node-classification-on-cora-3Snowball (linear + tanh)#6Accuracy: 79.52%
node-classification-on-cora-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-3#61:1 Accuracy: 89.33 ± 1.3
node-classification-on-cora-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-2#171:1 Accuracy: 88.64 ± 1.15
node-classification-on-pubmed-with-public-split-fixed-20-nodes-per-classTruncated Krylov#6Accuracy: 81.7%
node-classification-on-pubmed-with-public-split-fixed-20-nodes-per-classSnowball (tanh)#24Accuracy: 79.16%
node-classification-on-pubmed-with-public-split-fixed-20-nodes-per-classSnowball (linear)#25Accuracy: 79.10%
node-classification-on-citeseer-with-public-split-fixed-20-nodes-per-classTruncated Krylov#11Accuracy: 73.86%
node-classification-on-citeseer-with-public-split-fixed-20-nodes-per-classSnowball (tanh)#17Accuracy: 73.32%
node-classification-on-citeseer-with-public-split-fixed-20-nodes-per-classSnowball (linear)#25Accuracy: 72.85%
node-classification-on-non-homophilic-heterophilic-graphs-on-chameleon-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-3#131:1 Accuracy: 65.49 ± 1.64
node-classification-on-non-homophilic-heterophilic-graphs-on-chameleon-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-2#141:1 Accuracy: 64.99 ± 2.39
node-classification-on-chameleon-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-3#141:1 Accuracy: 65.49 ± 1.64
node-classification-on-chameleon-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-2#151:1 Accuracy: 64.99 ± 2.39
node-classification-on-citeseer-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-2#141:1 Accuracy: 81.53 ± 1.71
node-classification-on-citeseer-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-3#181:1 Accuracy: 80.93 ± 1.32
node-classification-on-squirrel-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-3#151:1 Accuracy: 48.25 ± 0.94
node-classification-on-squirrel-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-2#161:1 Accuracy: 47.88 ± 1.23
node-classification-on-cora-with-public-split-fixed-20-nodes-per-classSnowball (linear)#21Accuracy: 83.26%
node-classification-on-cora-with-public-split-fixed-20-nodes-per-classSnowball (tanh)#23Accuracy: 83.19%
node-classification-on-cora-with-public-split-fixed-20-nodes-per-classTruncated Krylov#24Accuracy: 83.16%
node-classification-on-pubmed-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-2#221:1 Accuracy: 89.04 ± 0.49
node-classification-on-pubmed-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-3#241:1 Accuracy: 88.8 ± 0.82
node-classification-on-cornell-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-3#231:1 Accuracy: 82.95 ± 2.1
node-classification-on-cornell-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-2#241:1 Accuracy: 82.62 ± 2.34
node-classification-on-non-homophilic-heterophilic-graphs-on-cornell-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-3#231:1 Accuracy: 82.95 ± 2.1
node-classification-on-non-homophilic-heterophilic-graphs-on-cornell-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-2#241:1 Accuracy: 82.62 ± 2.34
node-classification-on-non-homophilic-heterophilic-graphs-on-texas-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-2#231:1 Accuracy: 83.11 ± 3.2
node-classification-on-non-homophilic-heterophilic-graphs-on-texas-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-3#241:1 Accuracy: 83.11 ± 3.2
node-classification-on-non-homophilic-heterophilic-graphs-on-wisconsin-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-2#241:1 Accuracy: 74.88 ± 3.42
node-classification-on-non-homophilic-heterophilic-graphs-on-wisconsin-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-3#281:1 Accuracy: 69.5 ± 5.01
node-classification-on-texas-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-2#251:1 Accuracy: 83.11 ± 3.2
node-classification-on-texas-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-3#261:1 Accuracy: 83.11 ± 3.2
node-classification-on-film-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-3#261:1 Accuracy: 36.00 ± 1.36
node-classification-on-film-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-2#281:1 Accuracy: 35.97 ± 0.66
node-classification-on-wisconsin-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-2#271:1 Accuracy: 74.88 ± 3.42
node-classification-on-wisconsin-60-20-20-random-splitsSnowball-3#311:1 Accuracy: 69.5 ± 5.01